double, double, toil and trouble

Nine West, Seychelles, Aldo and Jeffrey Campbell are what a lot of us would call "trend" brands – lines that take inspiration from the runway and elsewhere. Seychelles is probably the least obvious/infrequent offender, while JC shoes in particular look like everything from the established Frye boots to the more independent Tashkent by Cheyenne.
Up until now, I'd only vaguely sensed the similarities between Jeffrey Campbell and Aldo. I'd never given it too much thought, though, mostly just fusing the two brands in mental haze. This past month, for sizing and other reasons, I ended up ordering online three pairs of a certain Aldo boot. (Thanks to ex-blogger Lauren of Fops and Dandies for the tip and discount code!) The peculiar thing was, when I opened up the three boxes of shoes, all three boxes had a warning note inside. The slip of paper concluded with, "Please visit www.jeffreycampbellshoes.com." Say what? I ordered shoes from Aldo, not JC. So why is there a warning from another brand inside there?
On a whim, I decided to do a little web sleuthing and found that JC was making almost the same exact boot I had bought from Aldo (which in themselves were both versions on the Marc by Marc Jacobs boot). Still confused, I started recollecting fragments of similarities in other models. More browsing revealed what I had suspected: Not one, not two, but many of JC's and Aldo's shoes were, for all intents and purposes, identical. Sometimes there's a little variation, such as a faux snakeskin versus a plain patent leather, but often even the minor details are the same, down to the shape of the footbed, the hardware or the type of closure.
I tend to be more of a Jeffrey Campbell person myself but have no particular allegiance to one over the other. (Although, I will say that the number of JC shoes on my shoe rack probably outnumber Aldo 2:1.) I also harbor no illusions that either brand is entirely original. What I wonder, though, is how are they so, so alike? Aside from the visible labels on the shoes, can you tell which shoe is which in these collages? (Answers below.) Also, what's up with getting JC warning labels in my Aldo shoe boxes?
If there's nothing else to learn from this comparison, at least we walk away with the knowledge that, when all JC purveryors run out of that black leather, wrap-around, zip up sandal-cutout-boot thing in our sizes (and both heel heights), Aldo might still have some in stock. Or vice versa.
Answer: In each pair or set, all Aldos are on the left and JCs are on the right.
Shoe images: Aldo, Jeffrey Campbell, Revolve Clothing, Sole Struck, Karmaloop, David Z, Urban Outfitters, Kitson, Jildor, nitro:licious, Fashion Toast.
Backgrounds: Office paper copier, Xerox machines for sale.





































